Extra Butter

About

Located at 125 Orchard St in the heart of New York City, Extra Butter has established itself as a destination for sneakerheads and those seeking a curated selection of footwear and apparel. The shop is known for its distinct atmosphere, featuring a unique interior design modeled after a movie theater. This creative approach extends beyond the retail floor, as the store occasionally hosts movie nights complete with popcorn, offering a community-focused experience that sets it apart from a standard shoe store. The staff at Extra Butter are frequently noted for their hospitality, often going out of their way to assist visitors with product recommendations or even local travel tips. Whether managing complex online orders or helping in-store shoppers find the right fit, the team is recognized for their professional and helpful demeanor. While the store is a popular stop for those hunting for unique releases and collaborations, it also serves as a neighborhood fixture. For those planning a visit, Orchard Street is closed to vehicular traffic on Sundays, making it an ideal time to explore the shop’s offerings in a more relaxed, pedestrian-friendly environment.

Reviews Extra Butter

Extra Butter is widely regarded as a unique destination for sneaker enthusiasts and shoppers, featuring a curated selection of footwear and apparel within a distinct, movie-theater-inspired atmosphere. While most customers praise the helpful staff and efficient online support, a minority of reviewers report negative experiences regarding in-store service and online order fulfillment.

Opening hours

Friday

11 AM–7 PM

Monday

11 AM–7 PM

Sunday

12–6 PM

Tuesday

11 AM–7 PM

Saturday

11 AM–7 PM

Thursday

11 AM–7 PM

Wednesday

11 AM–7 PM

Contact

• 125 Orchard St, New York, NY 10002
• (917) 722-6578
• extrabutterny.com